Powerful lobbyists have a choke hold on the General Assembly leadership, which is only too happy to enable the continued soaking of the most vulnerable Rhode Islanders
The Senate Committee on Commerce met on Tuesday afternoon to consider one bill, S0191, which would repeal that part of Rhode Island law that allows the continued existence of payday lending companies. According to the Economic Progress Institute, payday loans are high-cost loans designed to perpetuate “an ongoing cycle of debt.” These companies set up shop in economically distressed communities, often becoming the only option when people need money. Rather than assisting people during difficult economic times, payday lenders entrap people in debt with loans that can be as high as 260 percent APR.
This obvious evil in outlawed throughout the northeastern United States, with only Maine, Delaware and Rhode Island allowing the practice. Senator Harold Metts (Democrat, District 6, Providence) has introduced the bill six times in six years, to no avail. The bill similarly fails annually in the House, and it’s easy to see why.
Powerful, well-funded lobbyists with close relationships to the leadership of the Rhode Island General Assembly prevent this bill from being passed, making General Assembly leadership, such as Senate President Dominick Ruggerio (Democrat, District 4, Providence) and Speaker of the House Nicholas Mattiello (Democrat, District 15, Cranston) complicit in the practice of payday lending which soaks the most vulnerable of Rhode Islanders with fees of around $7.6 million a year.
The Senate Commerce Committee meeting was held in a room, 212, without cameras and without audio recording. When I entered and set up my camera, one of the women who works in the office asked if I was recording the meeting. I assured her that I was. She left the room. The room was full of lobbyists for payday loan companies such as Axcess Financial and Advance America. These lobbyists included former Speaker of the House William Murphy (Democrat, District 26, West Warwick). Advance America pays Murphy $30,000 a year to make sure payday lending is never outlawed in Rhode Island.
This article from the Providence Journal outlines the close relationship between Speaker Mattiello and former speaker, now lobbyist, William Murphy.
Can you help us?
Funding for our reporting relies on the generosity of readers like you. Our independence allows us to write stories that hold RI state and local government officials accountable. All of our stories are free and available to everyone. But your support is essential to keeping Steve and Will on the beat, covering the costs of reporting many stories in a single day. If you are able to, please support Uprise RI. Every contribution, big or small is so valuable to us. You provide the motivation and financial support to keep doing what we do. Thank you.
Before the meeting got going, Senate Majority Leader Michael McCaffrey (Democrat, District 29, Warwick) entered the room and glad handed the lobbyists. He sat in on a few minutes of the proceedings too, since as Majority Leader McCaffrey sits ex officio on all senate committees. He left as I began testifying, but the meeting was monitored after that by Senate Director of Communications Greg Paré.
No one directly representing the payday loan industry spoke at the hearing. Instead, the industry relied on written testimony from Carol Stewart, Senior Vice President of Government Affairs at Advance America and the oral testimony of Bill Staderman, President of the Rhode Island Association of Financial Services. Staderman began his testimony by saying that he was not a lobbyist.
Testimony against payday loans included written testimony from Rhode Island Kids Count, The State of Rhode Island Commission for Human Rights, Alan Krinsky from the Economic Progress Institute, and Kelly Rogers from the office of General Treasurer Seth Magaziner. Krinsky and Rogers also presented oral testimony.
It was never a contest, of course. Most Senators didn’t even bother to show up for the committee meeting, or if they did show up, cut out early. Chair Roger Picard (Democrat, District 20, Woonsocket) was absent, leaving the Committee to Vice-Chair Ana Quezada (Democrat, District 2, Providence). Admirably, Quezada is a co-sponsor of Metts’ bill, and expressed her desire to get this bill passed this year. The one Republican on the Committee, Senator Elaine Morgan (District 34, Exeter Hopkinton, Richmond, West Greenwich) never made an appearance, but Senate Minority Leader Dennis Algiere (Republican, District 38, Westerly, Charlestown) stuck his head in the doorway long enough to okay the meeting. Senator Hanna Gallo (Democrat, District 27, Cranston) was in and out of the meeting, present for the pro-payday loan testimony of Staderman, absent for most of the rest of the testimony, all of which was against payday loans.
This left the committee in the hands of Senators Quezada, Samuel Bell (Democrat, District 5, Providence) and Frank Lombardo (Democrat, District 25, Johnston). Bell stands opposed to payday loans, Lombardo seemed to favor them, based on his questioning.
After the oral testimony the committee voted 2-1 to hold the bill for further study, with Senator Bell dissenting.
The fight against payday loans in Rhode Island was once more robust, if equally doomed. The Rhode Island Interfaith Coalition to Reduce Poverty used to make the elimination of payday loans a top priority – Reverend Donnie Anderson once called payday loans “evil” – but the idea has fallen off the Coalition’s to do list in recent years.
The fix is in on payday loans in Rhode Island. The money that bad people can make by exploiting the poor and the vulnerable is too great. And our General Assembly is complicit in this “evil.”
Here’s video of all the testimony, followed by the written testimony. Oddly, when I requested all the written testimony, I did not get it all. I will amend the piece when I get my hands on the rest.
Senator Metts introduces the bill:
You can watch Senate Majority Leader Michael McCaffrey get up and walk out during my testimony:
Kelly Rogers from Treasurer Magaziner’s office:
Bill Staderman, President of the Rhode Island Association of Financial Services at one point used a report from the libertarian, Koch Brothers funded Cato Institute to support his arguments. The Cato institute is a leader in the movement to cast doubt on the science of climate change, and a bad actor on multiple fronts.
Alan Krinsky from the Economic Progress Institute:
Written Testimony from payday lender Advance America:
Written Testimony from the Economic Progress Institute:
Written testimony from Rhode Island Kids Count:
Written testimony from the State of Rhode Island Commission for Human Rights:
Written testimony from General Treasurer Seth Magaziner:
Here’s the sign-in sheet which clearly indicates that there was written testimony submitted by Nicholas Hemond and Stephen Alves that was not made available to me upon my request. Hemond is paid $20,000 per year by Axcess Financial. Stephen Alves is paid $40,000 per year by Axcess Financial.
UpriseRI is entirely supported by donations and advertising. Every little bit helps:
Become a Patron!